Papal Posture or Papal Compromise

Pope Francis’ comments in  recent interviews have surprised many, both in the Church and outside it. The most widely discussed comments, of course, deal with the Church’s advocacy of social issues, particularly abortion, homosexuality, and contraception. In proclaiming his desire that the Church be a “home for all”, he added to growing fears among conservative Catholics that the sanctity of life and marriage would not be a priority for the new pope. His vision seemed to be to craft a more inclusive Church that can reach younger generations who are increasingly preoccupied with many issues surrounding homosexuality.

Fortunately for the more orthodox wing of the Church, the Pope clarified his meaning in a talk given to an assembly of Catholic gynecologists on Sept 20th. “In all its phases and at every age, human life is always sacred and always of quality. And not as a matter of faith, but of reason and science!”

These comments put the former sensational headlines in a proper light. Many on the left have sought to characterize Francis’ position as more radical than it is. The intent of his comments seems to be to bring proper perspective back to the ministry of the Church. In a polarized world where social issues are typically the most controversial of topics, it does not make sense to lead with the most offensive part of the Christian message.The gospel is offensive enough to a world that has largely rejected Christ. Moreover, the great mercy, peace, and love contained in Christ’s redemptive message should always be the locus out of which our moral teachings flow.

In a culture where sexual practices tend to define our identities, Christians must accurately convey the grace available to all, regardless of their struggles. This does not detract one iota from the traditional morality proclaimed by the Church, rather, couches it in the hopeful message of the gospel. For more on the Pope’s comments please check out this excellent article.